When it’s time to get rid of your old mattress, you may not know where to start looking for a new one. Most mattress companies advertise that they offer the best mattresses, but how can you find the right one? Why not try an online mattress—they contain high-quality materials at lower prices, and there’s little risk of buyer’s remorse.
In our article, we share the best online mattresses in the industry and provide a guide on what to look for in an online mattress.
Best Online Mattresses
|Mattress||Highlights||Price for a queen size|
|Amerisleep AS3||Responsive, plant-based memory foam layer relieves pressure points with little to no off-gassing odor.||$1049|
|Zoma||3-zone support system in the comfort layer evenly relieves pressure points.||$750|
|Purple® Original||Gel-like, temperature-neutral comfort layer conforms to the body and maintains support.||$1099|
|Tuft & Needle Original||Graphite and gel pull heat away from the body and prevent overheating.||$595|
|Avocado Green||All-natural latex contours to the body and has a responsive bounce, making movement easier.||$1189|
|Aviya||Three layers of high-density foam combined with a 3-zone support of pocket coils evenly supports the body and relieves pressure points.||$1099|
|Boll & Branch||Natural latex layers regulate body temperature and prevent overheating.||$2500|
|Tulo||All-foam mattress with breathable layers available in three firmness options.||$699|
The Amerisleep AS3 mattress is 12 inches tall and contains 3 inches of Bio-Pur®, 2 inches of Affinity with HIVE® technology, and 7 inches of Bio-Core®. Amerisleep also features a soft, breathable cover designed to promote airflow so you always sleep cool and comfortable.
Bio-Pur® is a plant-based memory foam, where manufacturers partially replace petroleum with castor oil. The result is a breathable, more responsive memory foam—potential sleepers won’t have to worry about feeling “stuck” or overheating at night.
The Affinity uses HIVE® technology, where hundreds of hexagonal-shaped segments form a 5-zone support system. Softer support rests under the shoulders and hips with a firmer feel in the head, back, and legs. HIVE® evenly relieves pressure points in the body and encourages spinal alignment.
Bio-Core® is a durable base layer found in every Amerisleep mattress. This base layer supports the body without risk of sagging for a long-lasting mattress.
The Amerisleep AS3 mattress has a medium feel, the perfect choice for side and combination sleepers. Plush and supportive foams contour to the body, relieving pressure points especially in heavier sections of the body, like the shoulders and hips.
Amerisleep includes a 100-night sleep trial and a 20-year warranty, one of the best in the mattress industry. The warranty covers sagging greater than 0.75 inches and any defects which could damage the mattress. During the first 10 years, Amerisleep will repair or replace the bed free of charge. Afterwards, Amerisleep will repair or replace the mattress at a prorated charge.
The Zoma mattress is 11 inches tall and contains 2 inches of Triangulex™, 2 inches of Reactiv™, and 7 inches of Support+. The polyester knit mattress cover wicks away moisture and provides a soft sleep surface.
Triangulex™ is a comfort layer with a 3-zone support system, with softer support under the head, shoulders, and legs, and firmer support under the back and hips. Triangulex™ evenly supports the body and relieves pressure points. This high-density cooling gel memory foam conforms to the body, without bottoming out.
Reactiv™ is a latex-like foam—the foam contours to the body’s natural curves for enhanced pressure relief, encourages spinal alignment, and acts as a transitional layer between comfort and support.
Support+ is a high-density foam which reinforces the top layers while supporting the body, preventing sleepers from bottoming out.
The medium-firm feel of the Zoma mattress makes it a great option for most sleepers. The Zoma mattress is designed for athletes or those who lead an active lifestyle—body contouring, responsive foam layers relieve pressure points and may improve muscle recovery.
The Zoma mattress comes with a 100-night, risk-free trial and a 10-year warranty. For all 10 years, Zoma will repair or replace the mattress at no charge to the customer in case of sagging greater than 0.75 inches and any manufacturing defects.
3. Purple® Original
The Purple® Original mattress is 9.5 inches tall and contains 2 inches of Purple Grid™, 3.5 inches of poly-foam, and 4 inches of high-density foam. The mattress cover is made from a Lycra® blend for a soft and breathable surface.
The Purple Grid™ consists of Purple’s Hyper-Elastic Polymer™, a gel-like material formed in a grid system for better airflow inside the mattress. The Purple Grid™ gives under pressure to relieve pressure points without losing support.
The poly-foam transitional layer provides deeper compression in heavier sections of the body, like the shoulders and hips, for better pressure relief.
The high-density foam layer evenly distributes weight across the sleep surface with little risk of sagging.
The Purple® Original mattress has a medium feel, a good choice for side and combination sleepers. Temperature-neutral and highly responsive Purple Grid™ cradles the body, relieving pressure points while maintaining support.
Purple® includes a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year warranty. During the sleep trial, Purple® requires its customers to keep the mattress a minimum of 21 days, to allow the body to adjust to the new sleep surface. Purple’s® warranty covers any manufacturing defects and sagging greater than 1 inch.
4. Tuft & Needle Original
The Tuft & Needle Original mattress is 10 inches tall and contains 3 inches of T&N Adaptive® foam and 7 inches of high-density foam. The polyester and polyamide mattress cover is soft and breathable, preventing trapped heat.
T&N Adaptive® foam is a responsive poly-foam containing ceramic gel beads to absorb heat and graphite to keep heat away from the body. Potential sleepers won’t feel “stuck” and may find movement easier at night. The open-cell structure contains more air pockets and allows for better air circulation inside the mattress.
The high-density foam offers a supportive base for even weight distribution and reinforces the shape of the bed.
The medium-firm feel of the Tuft & Needle Original mattress is great for all types of sleepers—responsive foams prevent deep sinkage and ensure potential sleepers rest on the surface instead of bottoming out.
The Tuft & Needle Original mattress comes with a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year warranty. The warranty covers sagging greater than 0.75 inches and any manufacturing defects.
5. Avocado Green
The Avocado Green mattress is 11 inches thick and contains 2 inches of Dunlop latex, 8 inches of pocket coils, and a 1-inch base. The organic cotton mattress cover includes a layer of natural wool batting as a natural fire retardant.
The Dunlop latex is 100% natural and cooler than traditional memory foam. Latex forms around the body for pressure point relief.
The pocket coil layer forms a 5-zone support layer—softer feel under the shoulders and hips and firmer support under the head, back, and legs for targeted pressure relief. A base foam layer reinforces the top layers and maintains the shape of the bed.
The Avocado Green mattress has a medium-firm feel, however, for an extra fee, customers can add a 2-inch, Euro-style Dunlop latex pillow top which alters the bed to a medium feel. The mattress contains all-natural, sustainably-sourced materials, a great option for eco-conscious sleepers.
The Avocado Green mattress comes with a 1-year sleep trial and a 25-year warranty. For the sleep trial, Avocado asks customers to keep the mattress between 30 to 60 days to allow the body to adjust. The warranty covers sagging greater than 1 inch—during the first 10 years, Avocado fully covers costs for mattress repairs or replacements. Starting on the 11th year and until the end of the warranty, Avocado will replace the mattress at a prorated charge.
The Aviya mattress is 12 inches tall and contains three, 2-inch high-density foam layers, 5 inches of pocket coils, and 1 inch of base foam. The quilted mattress cover is made from cotton for a cool, plush sleep surface.
The top three layers of high-density foam are designed to provide a comfortable surface, conforming to the body and resist sagging. The use of high-density foam compared to lower density foams offers enhanced lumbar support.
The pocketed coiled layer contains a 3-support system with firmer support under the back and hips and softer support in the head, shoulders, and legs. A 3-inch thick foam perimeter lines the mattress for better edge support.
The Aviya mattress is available in 3 firmness options: plush, luxury firm, and firm. For this article, we chose the luxury firm. The luxury firm is the perfect medium for side and back sleepers. The mattress evenly supports the body and relieves pressure points in the shoulders and hips.
Aviya includes a 100-night trial and a 10-year warranty. The warranty covers sagging greater than 1 inch and defects which could damage the bed.
7. Boll & Branch
The Boll & Branch mattress is 13.5 inches thick and contains 1 inch of graphite-infused latex, 1 inch of Talalay latex, 1 inch of micro coils, and 8 inches of pocketed coils. The organic cotton mattress cover includes a 2.5-inch wool poly-blend layer to wick away moisture for extra loft and plushness.
The graphite-infused latex layer won’t trap heat and keeps heat away from the body.
Talalay is a natural latex with polyurethane fillers to create its signature softness. Talalay latex contains ventilation holes for better airflow—more breathable than traditional memory foam.
Micro coils isolate motion transfer and encourage spinal alignment.
Pocketed coils offer precise support in a 3-zone system. Lower-gauge coils provide a softer feel under the head, shoulders, and legs and higher-gauge coils under the back and hips for reinforced support. Tempered steel ensures the mattress lasts.
The medium-firm feel of the Boll & Branch mattress makes it a great choice for most sleepers—the firmer surface prevents deep sinkage and maintains even support. Boll & Branch offers its customers a free White Glove Delivery service, including old mattress removal.
Boll & Branch includes a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year warranty, covering sagging greater than 1.5 inches.
The Tulo mattress is 10 inches tall and contains 2 inches of cooling memory foam, 1.5 inches of breathable foam, 2 inches of responsive foam, and 4.5 inches of foundation foam. The knit mattress cover provides a soft, breathable surface.
The high-density, cooling memory foam is infused with titanium particles to pull heat away and ventilation holes for better airflow.
The breathable foam incorporates open-cell technology with more air pockets inside the material. The convoluted shape increases airflow inside the mattress.
Responsive foam prevents sleepers from bottoming out and enhances pressure relief in the body.
The foundation foam is the base layer of the Tulo mattress. Its firmness level depends on which mattress you choose—soft, medium, or firm. The foundation foam provides solid support without sagging.
The Tulo mattress has 3 firmness options to choose from—soft, medium, and firm. For our article, we choose the medium option. The medium feel is great for side and back sleepers, who need optimal pressure relief in the shoulders and hips for the best comfort and support.
The Tulo mattress comes with a 120-night sleep trial and a 10-year warranty. Tulo requires customers to keep the mattress at least 30 days before they’ll issue a refund. The warranty covers sagging greater than 0.75 inches.
Online vs. In-Store
Online mattress companies provide customers with high-quality mattresses at a lower price tag, plus extended sleep trials and easy returns. A major drawback to online shopping is the lack of opportunity to try out the mattress before buying. Also, since online mattresses include many bed-in-a-box brands, companies are less likely to offer a white glove delivery service.
Mattresses from brick and mortar stores allow potential shoppers to try the mattress before buying, with knowledgeable salesmen on hand to answer any questions. Most in-store companies offer same day or next day delivery. The downsides to in-store mattress shopping include pressure to buy from salesmen, short sleep trials, and potentially paying more.
What to Consider in an Online Mattress
Before buying a new mattress, take a look at mattress type, quality, and available sleep trials, return policies, and warranties. Keep in mind that the right firmness is based on your body type and sleeping position.
Each type of mattress offers potential shoppers their own unique feel. Some sleepers prefer the bounce of an innerspring, while others enjoy the conforming feel of memory foam.
When heat and pressure are applied, memory foam softens to form around the natural curves of the body, relieving pressure points and reducing aches and pains. Memory foam beds run the risk of overheating, however, choosing memory foam with cooling properties, like breathable plant-based foam or gel memory foam regulates body temperature.
A typical memory foam mattress contains layers of foam including a comfort layer of memory foam and a support layer of high-density foam.
Innerspring coil mattresses are more commonly found in households. Known for their bouncy surface and cooling properties, innersprings have excellent edge support for those who prefer sleeping on the edge of the bed. Some drawbacks to an innerspring mattress include motion transfer, less pressure relief, and noise potential.
An innerspring mattress contains a thin comfort layer (usually in pillow top form) of fiberfill or foam and a support layer of steel innerspring coils.
Latex resembles memory foam by conforming to the body to relieve pressure points. Latex is more sponge-like, cooler, and more responsive than traditional memory foam. There are two types of latex: synthetic and natural. Synthetic latex is created through a chemical process, while natural latex is made from rubber tree sap.
Two types of natural latex commonly found inside mattresses are Dunlop and Talalay. Dunlop is 100% natural and is denser and more durable than Talalay. Talalay latex contains polyurethane fillers for its signature soft feel.
A latex mattress contains a comfort layer of latex and a support layer of either high-density foam or latex.
Hybrid mattresses combine pressure-relieving memory foam and responsive innerspring coils to form the perfect mattress. Hybrids offer the best of memory foam and innerspring, but they also come with drawbacks, like the risk of overheating and motion transfer. Plus, hybrids are heavier and more expensive than other mattress types because of the number of materials they contain.
A hybrid mattress contains a comfort layer of memory foam or latex and a support layer of pocketed coils.
To determine material quality, take a look at the foam’s ILD rating and density, and coil count and gauge.
ILD, or Indentation Load Deflection, evaluates the foam’s firmness by measuring how much pressure it takes to make a 4-inch indentation on the surface—the higher the number, the firmer the foam. ILD ratings range between 8 (softest) and 20 (firmest) in the comfort layer. Potential shoppers should look for a 10 ILD rating for the best comfort and support.
Density is how the foam supports the body, measuring how long it takes for the foam to spring back into its original shape. Many mattresses contain a mix of low- and high-density foams, depending on the brand.
- Low-density: 2.5 to 3.9 PCF
- Medium-density: 4.0 to 5.9 PCF
- High-density: 5.5 PCF or higher
Coil count is the number of innerspring coils in a single layer. Quality mattresses contain between 500 to 1,000 coils. Avoid mattresses that contain 300 coils or less—these types of beds are more likely to breakdown within two years.
Coil gauge is the thickness of a coil. Measured in millimeters, coil gauge ranges between 12 millimeters (thickest) to 18 millimeters (thinnest). While thin coils are not a bad thing—they provide softer support—be wary of support layers containing only low-gauge coils, since they’re more likely to sag within a year.
One major factor in finding the right firmness is body type. Your weight needs a certain balance of comfort and support for a good night’s sleep. Weight is divided into three groups—light, average, and plus-size.
Light sleepers weigh less than 130 pounds. They need a softer surface to enable cushioning pressure relief.
Average sleepers weigh between 130 to 230 pounds. A medium surface is a great choice—the perfect balance of comfort and support.
Plus-size sleepers weigh more than 230 pounds. They need a firmer mattress to provide even support without risk of sagging.
Another major factor in choosing the right firmness is your favorite sleeping position. How you sleep determines how much cushioning and support your body needs for healthy spinal alignment.
Side sleeping is the healthiest sleeping position. It enables better breathing, reduces acid reflux symptoms, and improves heart health. Placing a pillow between the knees straightens the hips, preventing spinal misalignment.
Side sleepers need a soft to medium mattress for optimal pressure relief in the shoulders and hips and to fill in large gaps between the body and the mattress.
Back sleeping allows the spine to align naturally because of the back’s direct contact with the sleep surface. Risks involved with back sleeping include snoring and sleep apnea.
Back sleepers should look for a medium to firm mattress to cradle the hips and enhance lumbar support.
Stomach sleeping is one of the unhealthiest sleeping positions because of the amount of pressure placed on the spine. Heavy pressure can lead to neck strain and back pain, but placing a thin pillow under the hips can reduce this pressure. Alternatively, investing in the best mattress for back pain can prevent discomfort.
Stomach sleepers need a medium-firm to firm mattress to keep the body resting on top and prevent heavy sinkage.
Combination sleepers, or restless sleepers, switch between 2 to 3 sleep positions each night. They receive all the benefits of each sleeping position, like improved heart health and natural alignment, but they also get the drawbacks, including snoring and neck strain.
Combination sleepers need a medium to medium-firm mattress to maintain alignment and for consistent comfort and support.
Sleep Trial, Return Policy, and Warranty
Sleep trials, return policies, and warranties are reassurances to the customer of a quality mattress purchase.
A sleep trial allows customers to try out a new mattress within the comfort of their own home. These trial periods usually last between 90 to 120 nights, with some mattress companies requiring their customers to keep the mattress at least 30 days to let the body adjust. If the customer doesn’t like the mattress, most online mattress companies will pick up and donate the bed before issuing a full refund.
A return policy is a good substitute if a mattress doesn’t come with a sleep trial. Most return policies last 30 days—about the same time it takes for the body to adjust to a new sleep surface. If the customer isn’t happy with the mattress, they can return it for a refund.
Warranties cover any manufacturing defects which could damage the mattress and sagging greater than 1 inch (the measurement varies, depending on the brand). Most mattresses come with a standard 10-year warranty and only applies to the original purchaser.
Which is better, foam or spring mattress?
Memory foam is the better choice because of its excellent pressure-relieving properties and ability to maintain its original shape.
Is it better to sleep on a hard or soft mattress?
The mattress firmness depends on your favored sleeping position and body weight. The right mattress contours to your body to relieve pressure points while evenly supporting your body for healthy spinal alignment.
Can a mattress cause back pain?
A mattress that is too firm, too soft, lumpy, or sagging can lead to back pain. You want a mattress that fits the “Goldilocks” standard with an even balance of comfort and support.
When looking for a new bed, consider an online mattress. Online mattress companies offer high-quality beds at lower costs—you won’t have to worry about pressure to buy, plus you get an extended sleep trial to try out a new mattress at home. The best online mattress is just a click away.